In her seminal book, The Human Condition, the German-American political thinker, historian, and philosopher Hannah Arendt posed forgiveness as humanity’s ultimate remedy for the irreversible. An Augustinian thinker at heart (and a disciple of Romano Guardini and Rudolf Bultmann), her insights resonate deeply with some of the core teachings on forgiveness found in Christian traditions.
Arendt argues that forgiveness is not a moral virtue, but a necessary response to the inherent unpredictability of human actions and their consequences. In a famous chapter titled "Irreversibility and the Power to Forgive," she contends that forgiveness becomes most crucial when faced with actions that seem beyond repair or redemption.
Indeed, forgiveness is needed to deal with wounds that seem insurmountable. When wounds are superficial or easily forgettable, then they do not seem to require forgiveness at all.
Central to Arendt’s exploration is the recognition that forgiveness is not necessarily about pardoning. Forgiveness is an existential, constitutive human capacity to handle the past without forgetting or dismissing it, while still building a path toward future renewal.
Indeed, Arendt suggests that through forgiveness, individuals and societies can confront the consequences of wrongdoing without perpetuating cycles of revenge. While revenge’s time is cyclical and thus “natural” (everything in nature moves cyclically, Arendt reminds the reader) forgiveness’ time is borderline miraculous (and thus “supernatural”). Forgiveness is a radically new beginning.
From the ancient world
Arendt notes that, in the ancient world, very few authors and traditions considered forgiveness as a viable solution for anything. But a central historical figure acknowledged the transformative potential of forgiveness: Jesus of Nazareth.
Arendt portrays Jesus as the “discoverer” of forgiveness in human affairs, emphasizing his teachings on turning the other cheek and forgiving seventy times seven as revolutionary acts that defy conventional notions of justice and retribution.
Christian readers will find in these insights an invitation to ponder the deeper human, spiritual, dimensions of forgiveness. Arendt challenges us to recognize forgiveness as a cornerstone of human dignity and freedom. By embracing forgiveness, individuals reclaim agency over their emotional and moral landscapes, transcend the limitations imposed by past grievances, and pave the way for possible healing and, ultimately, reconciliation.
Not surprisingly, Arendt’s reflections on forgiveness in The Human Condition resonate deeply with Catholic tradition. They emphasize forgiveness as a transformative force that transcends the irreparable and offers a path to spiritual, social, political, and emotional renewal.
In accepting and granting forgiveness, individuals embrace their common humanity and affirm their capacity for grace in the face of the inevitable harm we cause each other, even if unwillingly.
